The Fraud Codex

Back to all sites

Is Etsy a Scam?

etsy.comLegitimate Business
Risk Assessment
20%Risk Score
Low Risk

Summary

Etsy is a legitimate, publicly-traded marketplace (NASDAQ: ETSY) for handmade, vintage, and unique items. Strong buyer protection but quality depends on sellers.

Etsy is NOT a scam. Purchase Protection covers most issues. Check seller reviews and shop policies before ordering.

Company Information

Parent Company
Etsy, Inc.
Founded
2005
Headquarters
Brooklyn, NY
Stock
NASDAQ: ETSY
Employees
2,500+

Trust Indicators

Concerns

  • Some sellers resell mass-produced itemsmedium[source]
  • Shipping times vary by sellerlow[source]
  • Quality depends on individual sellermedium[source]
BBB Rating
A+
Trustpilot
1.6/5
BBB Complaints
2,800

💡 Recommendations

  • 1.Read seller reviews and policies
  • 2.Check estimated shipping times
  • 3.Message seller with questions first
  • 4.Use Purchase Protection for disputes
  • 5.Look for "Star Seller" badge

📚 Sources

Etsy Investor RelationsSEC EDGAR - Etsy FilingsNASDAQ - ETSY StockBBB Business ProfileEtsy Purchase Protection
Last updated: 2026-01-22

Disclaimer: This analysis is for informational purposes only. Information may be incomplete, outdated, or inaccurate. Our assessments should not be the sole basis for financial, legal, or personal decisions. Always conduct your own research and due diligence.